I've been wanting to review the 5 pages of responses and summarize the findings, but what I will say before (if?) I get to that:
There seems to be three primary audiences that PW is catering to, or that it can potentially cater to:
Developers (ease of development, API, headless, documentation, module development/sales, etc)
Clients (security, continuously developed, version stability, availability of developers)
Consumers: A developer and client all in one (all the ways in which it competes, and how it's different)
It may not be evidently clear what the project is primarily aimed at catering to, and perhaps that needs to be clarified, whether directly by Ryan in terms of what he is interested/able in supporting, or by the community's desire (as Ryan seems amicable to our opinions on steering it). That may also help guide any potential website redesigns. I think this is an important question to really consider and have answered. Although it can be done, it's really hard to properly target all three of the above, all at once.