Alan N Posted October 29 Posted October 29 Hi all, I'm looking at using ProcessWire for the first time. I have used Joomla for a long time through my employment but am looking for something less heavy for other projects. I have extensively used Joomla's modules (mostly the custom HTML ones) and leaned heavily on its ability to publish those modules on specific pages in specific positions. Is there anyone that has switched from Joomla that could let me know about their experience? Thank you in advance.
Peter Knight Posted October 30 Posted October 30 Hi Alan, I can’t honestly say I’ve migrated a site from Joomla. However, some time ago I briefly had to use Joomla for a client site. I recall often wondering why simple things in ProcessWire were so unnecessarily complicated in Joomla. Possibly no help to you but I think you’ll quickly like PW. P
Alan N Posted October 31 Author Posted October 31 Hi Peter, Thanks for your reply. It's always awkward when comparing. I never considered Joomla as complicated - but then nothing is when you're used to it! Unfortunately, I've not got past first base as after 3 installations of ProcessWire on different hosts, everything in admin is locked and displays padlocks - the admin also shows a key icon which suggests a lock of some sorts. I tried adding a new superuser but logging in with that one made no difference. I'm still looking for what I might have missed but no luck so far! Regards, Alan 2
Peter Knight Posted October 31 Posted October 31 Hi Alan. That’s sounds odd and not a very good first impression. 😬 Do you mean you can access the admin but the pages in the tree have lock icons displayed beside each? Any way to share screenshots? P
Alan N Posted October 31 Author Posted October 31 Hi Peter, I'm away at moment so can't send screenshot. In the admin tree the "admin" link at the top has a key icon. All the pages below and other links have black padlock icons. It feels as if it's something that is enabled during installation that you disable once installed. I've not had time to dig into it. Thank you, Alan
Macrura Posted November 2 Posted November 2 The padlocks on the page tree means whatever template those pages are using have permissions configured on them to prevent them from displaying to the guest role, IIRC. 1
sleepycron Posted November 3 Posted November 3 On the modules-in-positions part: there's no direct equivalent, but what people usually do is a hidden "blocks" page with a repeater, plus a page reference field on each page to pick which blocks show up there. A bit of setup at first, but after that it's less clicking than Joomla's module manager.
Alan N Posted November 4 Author Posted November 4 Thanks @Macrura @sleepycron. Hi @Peter Knight This was my screenshot. Everything is locked for editing. If I try to do anything I get:
taotoo Posted November 4 Posted November 4 20 minutes ago, Alan N said: Thanks @Macrura @sleepycron. Hi @Peter Knight This was my screenshot. Everything is locked for editing. If I try to do anything I get: You're looking at the contents of the Admin menu, which you don't normally need to access. Your website pages - when you have some - will appear directly under Home. You could close the Admin section to avoid confusion. 2
Peter Knight Posted November 4 Posted November 4 As @taotoo says, you're looking at the admin sub section. Any pages you create would live as direct children of your Home parent. See following: 1
Alan N Posted November 4 Author Posted November 4 Thank you @taotoo and @Peter Knight. Thanks both for the clarifications. That makes sense now, I just found it strange seeing areas locked to a super user. Best Regards, Alan 1
Macrura Posted November 4 Posted November 4 @Alan N those are not locked to superuser; the icon is telling you that those are access controlled; As a SuperUser you can open them, access them. If that was not the case you would not be looking at the admin. The PW admin is just another PW page, running a process module. Admin itself is perm gated, and pages under can be gated to any user with admin access, depending on how you structure it for your needs. Specific Process modules work that way by showing or not showing based on if the role has a specific permission. You may want to try installing a more elaborate starter profile, like the Blog Profile to see how it all works... 1
Alan N Posted November 5 Author Posted November 5 @Macrura Thank you for your help with this. Much appreciated for all the assistance from you all - @taotoo and @Peter Knight. I'm impressed with the engagement and friendliness within the ProcessWire Support Forum. Best Regards, Alan 2
cst989 Posted Wednesday at 04:02 PM Posted Wednesday at 04:02 PM The main thing to consider between the two is that ProcessWire is far less opinionated than Joomla, and its modules are almost entirely designed to aid developers in data organisation. "Modules" in Joomla are something very different. They're often commercial, they're meant to be configured by CMS users, and will have a lot of control of what exactly is output on the front-end of the site. In ProcessWire the onus is much more on the developer to organise templates and fields themselves and write the output, rather than expecting a third-party system to be responsible for any of it. 1
Alan N Posted yesterday at 09:17 AM Author Posted yesterday at 09:17 AM @cst989 Thank you. I'm not a developer, I'm more a site administrator, leveraging CMS functionality. The Joomla modules I was talking about are the core ones - over the years I have avoided commercial modules wherever possible - nowadays you can do pretty much everything you need with the Joomla core - if you're prepared to put some work in. I can probably say the biggest reason I've stayed with Joomla is the functionality to target supplementary content on specific pages in specific places. I do agree with you on the opinionated side of things. I also like the ProcessWire approach with fields and templates - and clean frontend output. In some ways ProcessWire reminds me of Drupal. I steered away from Drupal for a number of reasons but I always liked it's field driven approach. In hindsight, I should have been looking at ProcessWire! 1
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now