Jump to content
shadowkyogre

Not sure how to represent suborganizations for my use case

Recommended Posts

[EDIT]: After sitting down and planning out my site according to the ragged hierarchy information, I settled on the following schematics.

  • /$world/$template/$content_of_template_type/... for my pretty URLs
  • /roster/$character for my characters
  • a generic Repeater field with depth on most content types for custom positions for child pages to connect to instead of it directly
  • a few Repeater fields on each content that have (PageReference[1], other fields) to establish associations
  • A few FieldsetGroups to help me manage the fields that I needed to copy across a bunch of content types.

Kept the original post below for context and tagged the OP for searchability.

---

Hi everyone! I'm working on a personalized worldbuilding wiki to host my art and story stuff.

Right now my site architecture looks like...

  • /$world/cosmology/$cosmology
  • /$world/locations/$location
  • /$world/factions/$faction
  • /$world/history/$history
  • /$world/species/$species
  • /roster/$character

So far the layout works, but there's one problem. I need to make sub-sections for an organization. Organizations can appear under cosmology, locations, and factions. Sounds straightforward until... I run into the problem of figuring out how to represent subfactions.

Key factors in this are...

  • Characters should be able to be part of multiple organizations
  • Characters should have an explicit role assigned to their membership.
  • Character pages should be able to query the organization pages to display their ranks across organizations.
  • Editing an organization's hierarchical layout should be visible while editing the root organization page.

From what I've read of the ProcessWire documentation, the best use case for each way of representing the organization's subsections are...

  • Child Pages:: Works best for menu presentation and dedicated editing.
  • PageTables:: Works if you want control over where to place the PageTable fields, but requires opening a modal for the pages you want to edit. It's also kind of like normal pages.
  • Repeaters:: Works great for inline editing and easy control over hierarchy, but the page urls become obscure.
  • Sections in the body field:: Works for copypasting from my note files. But it doesn't expose relationships for easy querying.

It looks like my best case for this is child pages since it allows displaying suborganization in the URL easily. But also I lose out on quickly reordering and editing the child pages. Any advice for people running into similar use cases?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would consider how other systems work out the mapping of ragged hierarchies - where you store a hierarchy level in addition to the ancestors and children relationships. Having a two dimensional structures like this enables you to manage granularity level control as well as lineage control. It becomes trivial to isolate branch grouping based on a limit of the lineage and level - say less than three. Alternatively, you can also build queries that select peers across a given landscape. For example, if local heroes of a klan that is a subfaction of a race on a given world, you can list them alongside heroes that are also part of major clans without internal divisions, or even immortal heroes without lineage or clan that live on a mountaintop on a continent. Each 'level' number represents a granularity level, not necessarily a power, quality or quantity level.

The nice thing about this method is that it allows you to 'skip' levels while still retaining lineage integrity if you so choose.

Here's an example of building such a data structure for an unrelated BI tool, but I think you will understand the design pattern. Perhaps this is what you are looking for:

https://www.dundas.com/support/learning/documentation/analyze-data/create-a-ragged-hierarchy

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Gorny!

I wrote some of my data hierarchy in the format shown in the link as part of a brainstorming exercise. After doing so, I could see why I'd need to arrange it in a ragged hierarchy. I do have cases where some characters play a big role in the world without that role being tied to participation in an organization.

From a ProcessWire standpoint, I could see the information from the article and your post translating into the following::

  • Using the normal parent/child relationship in ProcessWire for pretty urls only (which'd make doing a site map really easy).
  • Current site has granularity levels of the following. World > (Location | Era | Cosmology) > Organization > Role > Species > Character . Each of these is probably going to be a template, though that's a lot of copypasting same fields from basic-page. But it'd also make querying specific data types easier. I'm still not entirely sure what to do with the basic-page template here since I still use that for many basic pages that just have information, but no need for granular relationship participation.
  • Example use cases I could think of with my own data include...
    • Some organizations have Organization > Role > Species and some have Organization > Role > _ > Character
    • Characters can be biologically classified by their Species > Character relationship. I'm not sure how wise it is to use a repeater with a single page reference and a text field to store additional variation information. Sometimes I just want to make bird characters without a wiki entry for each type of bird instead of grouping it into a broader biological category. Like having some ravens and peacocks, but filing raven and peacock characters under a generic talking animals page.
    • Some characters are notable across the world for a reason. So they may have a World > _ > _ > Role > _ > Character.
    • There are some Locations that aren't bound to a world. So they might not have a parent.
    • It might be useful in some cases to flip Role and Organization around. Like if a Location has a different relationship with an Organization, it might be useful to have a Location > Role > Organization role that reads "Enemy" and another that reads "Ally" for those role nodes.
  • Modeling multiple parents for each leaf by the following...
    • A Page Reference field for the worldbuilding data type that's just "parents", where all worldbuilding page template types are valid parents. Sloppy visually, but, it works?
    • A Page Reference field for each type of worldbuilding page template that can be a valid ragged hierarchy parent for a page. Might be a lot of field overhead though, but that's probably better for form readability.
  • After modeling the multiple parentage, if I understand how to model this in PW with the given available tools, a few other things I could do with this are...
    • A character page can query what bloodline they have by checking the Species > Character, as mentioned before.
    • A character can list specific roles they have for organizations by checking for Organization > Role > Character.
    • A character can list organizations they participate in, but don't have a chain of command role by checking their direct Organization parent.
    • Character specific roles could simply have no parent or World parents according to the page reference fields, but in the page tree could be stored directly under the character.
    • Organizations can list all members that don't have a role by checking for no Organization > Role > Character relationships, but there being an Organization > _ > Character relationship.
    • Chain of commands in organizations can be handled with nested Role relationships with the rootmost Roles being direct children of the Organization.

If there's anything I missed from my understanding that I'd need to consider, please let me know.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The only thing I might suggest is that the Location Role and Organization Role seems like two different classifications - The tricky part that I see in general is that some of the items you talk about would be at the hierarchical level - say, at the vertical level of granularity - while other items are on at a description attribute levels - the horizontal level of classification.

Ultimately you will need to make some decisions with regard to what is considered an attribute and what is considered a degree of precision or size. I think the part that might mess with your head a bit is that there are likely going to be very common attributes of a variety of hierarchies. The advantage I can see from a PW perspective is that you could generate queries that pull selector values regardless of where they are in the hierarchy - but in terms of navigation structure I am not really sure how you would want to go about it without using URLSegments or something.

I have not tried to model out something that complicated in terms of URL structure - hopefully someone with more experience in tweaking segments can offer input...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By carlitoselmago
      I'm building a fieldtype/inputfield to visually select a grid like Bootstrap since it's the first time coding such thing, I'm basing my code in FieldtypeColorPicker since the base structure is the same, a graphical UI helper to finally output a string as value.
      The problem is I try to save the value as something like "1,2,3" referencing the index of each column selected but it gets converted as an int value so "1,2,3" becomes "1" if input random text it gets converted as "0".
      Here is the code:
      https://github.com/carlitoselmago/FieldtypeGridSpace
      Here's an screenshot of how it looks

    • By ICF Church
      Hi 👋
      Anyone else having this problem?
      Requirements:
      - Repeater (matrix & normal) with mutlilanguage fields (text, textarea…) 
      - Backend language set to something other than default (ie. German) 
      Reproduce:
      - Add a new repeater Item (ajax, I found no way to possible to disable it with matrix)

      (Notice how the default language tab is active instead of the backend language…)
      - Write something into the (default language) field
      - Try to save, if field is required, this will not work. If not required, then when reloading, the content will be inside the backend language field, instead of the default language field who was (presumably) active
      Analysis:
      When  loading  a new repeater element with ajax, the default langue tab is active, but the backend language inputfield is visible (with no visual indication). When writing into the field, it will populate the backend language. When manually clicking on the default language tab (which is already active), the field will switch to the actual default language field (which is [now] empty) (that can now be populated…)
      Also Notice, the labels of the elements to be added are in default language as well instead of the translated label (images instead of Bilder)…
      ProcessWire 3.0.148, Profields 0.0.5…
      Is it my system configuration, or does anyone else have the same issue? This is a screen recording of the problem:
      Issue: https://github.com/processwire/processwire-issues/issues/1179

      Screen Recording 2020-02-25 at 14.18.31.mov
    • By neonwired
      I have a front end form for creating new pages, repeater and repeater matrix field don't seem to save any data. I was considering handling the data manually but can't seem to get anything useful from the post data, are there any methods i can use?
    • By bramwolf
      Hi Guys,

      I found that my site is producing this notice on the front end, even when $config->debug = false and also when admin is
      not even logged in. How do I keep the site from displaying this message to front end users? The notice is about a few vars
      being tested, which in this case aren't defined, how would I stop that from happing all together when testing vars? if I for instance
      wrap the $discountCode = blabla in a if($order) { ...  } statement than I'm again testing for $order which isn't a object in this case
      which throws another notice..

      This is the notice:


      Here is my current code:
      // PAD DISCOUNT CODE HOOK // First we see if we have active discount code if ($this->session->orderId) { $order = $this->pages->get($this->session->orderId); } if($product->geen_korting == 1) { $nodisc = $product->geen_korting; } else { $nodisc = $product->parent->geen_korting; } $discountCode = $this->sanitizer->selectorValue($order->pad_discount_code); $dc = $this->pages->get("template=paddiscount, title=$discountCode"); if ($dc->id) { if ($nodisc) { $discount = 0; } elseif ($dc->pad_percentage) { $discount = $newprice * ($dc->pad_percentage / 100); } } $event->return = $newprice - $discount;
      Thanks in advance 🙂
    • By neophron
      Hi,
      I'm having trouble with a maybe simple code:
      I created a repeater (gallery_logos_links) and a repeater matrix (RepeaterMatrix_unternehmen). The repeater (gallery_logos_links) is inside the matrix repeater as a matrix type.
      The repeater matrix type is: gallery_logos_links and the image filed from the repeater is single_image.
       
      This my code:
      <?php foreach ($page->RepeaterMatrix_unternehmen as $item) { if ($item->type == 'gallery_logos_links') { echo " {foreach($item->repeater_logos_links as $logo)} <img src='{$logo->single_image->url}' alt='{$logo->single_image->description}' width='400'> {endforeach} "; } else if ($item->type == 'some_stuff') { echo"  
       
×
×
  • Create New...